Bob de Bakker

I loved Margret in the first book and when I saw she was the one of the main protagonist of this book I was excited! and luckily the book did not disappoint. I think it is my favorite so far of this series.

Only thing that I found weird was Judith. She has not been mentioned much until this book (to my memory) and knowing she will close this series of felt a bit rushed suddenly.

For the first 4 issues I was wondering what I would wish, then I got distracted with what would happen next in the story. It is a nice short ride.

It was different than I expected. More like the liveaction Alice in wonderland with weird magic everybody reacts to as if it is normal. While I from reviews expected something weird and wacky, cracking jokes every couple of lines. But still an enjoyable listen.

My favorite secret project yet. It was awesome to have a glimpse in the future of the cosmere, and loved the story.

I understand the criticism of this book. It has its moments of cringe. But overall I really enjoyed this book and how it ended. I am excited for what is next in the Cosmere.

It was a bit confusing to follow at times. With the jump in technology. But it was oké.

Not my favorite 🤷🏻‍♂️

This had the possibility to be my first Brandon Sanderson book. But I chose a book about souls and music instead. Glad after reading a big portion of the cosmere to finally finally have read it. It was a fun journey!

My favorite so far in the series. And the Saints of steel were amazing as always.

I am left speechless! I loved this book.

Omg I loved this book! Especially chapter 12 I want a novella with Kaladin and Adonlin adventures cannon or not.

But that ending I did not see it coming with odium. And the epilogue left me curious what Hoid is up to.

I really enjoyed this sea-faring adventure!

It was really satisfying seeing what kind of things happened behind the scenes. It was great to watch Kelsier in action again after his quick demise in the original series and I am interested what is to come in the future. Loved seeing all the connections to other books or novellas.

I got spoiled on some of the details of this book. But it was still a great adventure!

It had some great highs.

I disliked Lift in words of radiance. But while reading this novella I grew to love her. Such a fun and interesting character.

More details on kolos are given.

My only criticism of this book is the pacing of the beginning. Unlike the first book, which had a slower, more deliberate rhythm, this one felt rushed at the beginning.

Don't have anything to add to what has not already been said about the book. It is focused on setting up the world of Roshar and has a satisfying end, leaving you wanting more.

It's a fun "missing chapter". Much better than the 11th metal.

Really enjoyed the story and the magic system. Loved Vivenna story in the book and Vasher was my favorite character.

Spoopy

It's written too much like a book and didn't really let the panels tell the story. Every panel had descriptions like "He dodged it," something you can also see. The art is also very inconsistent.

It's a beautiful story that tells a lot with few pages.

A bit slow at times. But still a fun story, especially halfway through the book when the story develops further and comes together at times.